Kicker Wall of Shame 2025

This year's Kicker Wall of Shame.

No serious accuracy report here— just a fun and cathartic way to deal with each week’s biggest disappointments.

To qualify, a kicker normally needs to be high in my ranked list (top 8-ish) and score <5 points.

Here was a link to a previous year's.

Week 1: Matt Gay at #5 3 pts.

Week 2: Lutz at #5 3 pts.

Week 3: Bust week all around. Romo #1 with -2 pts. Boswell at #4 with 3 pts. Elliot at #6 with 3 pts. Little at #10 with 4 pts.

Week 4: No true busts! Though Dicker at #1 with 5 points is borderline.

Week 5: Whoa… another bust week, like Week 3 but maybe worse. No bright spots! Ryland at #2 with 3pts. Shrader (RIP) at #3 with 2pts. McAtamney at #7 with 2pts. Myers at #8 with 3pts. Even Bates at #1 with 5 pts can be considered borderline bust. (Elliott and Karty also 5 points, at #5 and #6).

Week 6: Prater at #2, with 2pts. Little at #8 with a surprising -1pts!

Week 7: Gay at #4 with 2pts.

Week 8:

Week 9:

Week 10:

Week 11:

Week 12:

Week 13:

Week 14:

Week 15:

Week 16:

Week 17: